The Difference Between the Voice Of "Should" and the Voice of "Is"
Prefer to listen? Click here:
There are two voices. I want to describe them carefully, because learning to tell them apart is one of the most useful things you can do for the rest of your life.
The first voice speaks in should. You should be further along by now. You should be more grateful. You should want what you have. You shouldn’t need so much. Who do you think you are?
The second voice speaks in is. The truths of what is for you. This isn’t right for me. I’m tired. I need more of this. That felt true. Something is wrong here.
The first voice is louder. It is faster. It often sounds exactly like you — it has learned your syntax, your specific brand of self-doubt, the particular flavor of criticism that lands hardest.
The second voice is quieter. It speaks in sensation as often as in words. It is easily overridden. And if you’ve spent a lifetime practicing the overriding, it may have gone very quiet indeed.
The conditioned voice tells you what you should do. The instinctual voice tells you what is true. They are not the same thing. And learning to tell them apart changes everything.
Why the conditioned voice is so convincing
It sounds like you. That’s the most disorienting part. It is woven into your interior monologue so completely that most people, when they first start this work, can’t imagine that the critical, urgent, comparative voice inside their head isn’t simply their authentic self.
But here’s how you know it isn’t: the conditioned voice makes you smaller. It contracts you. It pulls you toward what is safe and acceptable and approved of.
The instinctual voice, when you learn to hear it, does the opposite. It expands you. Even when it says something difficult — this isn’t working, I need to leave, this isn’t mine to carry — there is a quality of spaciousness in it. A quality of rightness.
The should vs. is practice
When you’re about to make a decision — any decision, large or small — pause for a moment and ask: is this a should or an is?
A should comes from outside. It is a rule, an expectation, a pressure, a fear of what will happen if you don’t comply. A should has urgency. It often arrives before you’ve had time to check in with your body.
An is comes from inside. It is simply a true thing. It doesn’t need defending or justifying. It has a quality of settledness, even when what it’s saying is hard.
You don’t have to act differently on this information yet. Just notice. Just name it. ‘That’s a should.’ Or: ‘That’s actually true for me.’
Over time, the instinctual voice gets louder. Not because it has changed — but because you started listening.
And then comes the question that almost no one talks about: what do you do when you hear her, and the conditioned voice is still louder? What do you do when you practice the noticing, and you still act from the wrong one — not from weakness, but because the pattern in your body is faster than your intention?
That’s not a practice problem. That’s a nervous system problem. And it requires nervous system work to clear.
The should vs. is practice I’ve given you here is real, and it will change things when you use it consistently. But if you want to go to the level where the conditioned voice actually loses its grip — not just gets noticed, but genuinely quiets — that work happens somewhere deeper.
Here’s what I’ve watched happen with women who come to this work through a seminar, a retreat, a viral framework, even years of therapy: they get the awareness. They understand the two voices. They can name which one is speaking. And then life gets loud, the old patterns move faster than the new intention, and the conditioned voice takes back the microphone. Not because they failed. Because a practice without a container — without consistent, body-level reinforcement over time — tends not to hold. What actually changes the grip of the conditioned voice isn’t insight or willpower. It’s sustained nervous system work in an environment safe enough for the pattern to release. That’s what The Richey Method™ provides. That’s what a practice community does. That’s the difference.
The Transforming Force is where this work, and The Richey Method gets lived, not just understood. Each week inside the membership, you receive a teaching a deeper-dive that takes you further, a Sacred Spark ritual that gives you time to embody the work rather than just absorb it, and three gentle touchpoints that reach into your ordinary life and point you back to yourself when the noise gets loud. Once a month, we meet live. What changes for women who stay: they stop asking why they keep repeating the same patterns. They start understanding where those patterns came from — and how to actually shift them. Not just in a journal. In their bodies. In their daily choices. In the quality of who they are when no one’s watching.I built this because it’s what I would have given anything to have when I was coming out of my own dark night of the soul. It exists because that woman deserved more than inspiration. And so do you. I invite you to join us here: https://judithrichey.com/tf-membership